Tagged: Julio Borbon

Borbon Designated…For Stupidity?

Almost immediately after the game yesterday, Julio Borbon was designated for assignment.  In the ninth inning, Borbon made a Grade A Stupid Play, bringing TOOTBLAN to a whole new level.

If you ask Dale Sveum, he would have you believe the two events are closely related, via Bruce Miles:

“That, obviously, was an unfortunate thing that happened.  It is a point that we just can’t keep having those things go on, and he’s had a few of them himself. So it was time to make an adjustment to the roster and see if somebody else can do the job.  Those are things that are controllable. You don’t have control over swinging at a slider in the dirt. Nobody’s wanting to do that. Those are physical things. Things you have complete control over is knowing the game and thinking ahead, understanding the ramifications. In that situation, you mean absolutely nothing at that point. You can literally stand on second base and not do anything, and everything will be perfectly fine.”

When I read that, I have to admit, my BS detector went nuts.  While Dale is correct when he points out that there have been multiple instances of Borbon running himself off the bases, he would also be correct if he said that about every Cub this season.  If he wanted to send a message about poor play, why does David DeJesus have a job?  He was completely brutal yesterday, and he’s had a number of concentration lapses that have directly led to runs scoring as an outfielder.

The answer is simple…Borbon was the 25th man.  He was probably on his way out the door soon, even if he would have hit a walk-off grand slam yesterday.  At some point in the near future, Ryan Sweeney and Brian Bogusevic are going to be coming back.  The Cubs have also been mighty left-handed this season.  At least for the time being, Donnie Murphy, who was added to the roster today, is a right handed hitter who has hit pretty well at AAA Iowa.

My guess is, he’ll be on the first bus back to Des Moines when either Sweeney or Bogusevic return.  And newcomer Cole Gillespie will likely get the boot, also.  Dale and the front office just happened to fall bass-ackwards into an opportune time to send a message to Junior Lake (who’s run into his share of stupid outs in just a couple of weeks), and the other youngsters who are watching the big league club from the minor leagues.  And he was right to do it.  It just doesn’t mean that what he said was the whole truth.

Cubs Roster Still Short a Couple of Pieces

I’ll never cease to be amazed by the amount of discontent that occurs during a losing streak.  And, at the same time, how quickly it disappears when the team wins four out of five.

As we were reminded this week, however, the roster is not complete, and will not be that way for quite some time.

  • Matt Garza had a “setback,” in that his arm got tired.  I wasn’t terribly concerned at the time because “dead arm” is something a lot of pitchers go through in Spring Training (which is pretty much where Garza is now).  While it makes the news, and subsequently makes fans fall all over themselves about the guy being fragile and not worth the trouble, it’s really nothing.  Until it has a reason to be something.  Garza is now scheduled to pitch on May 1, so while his rehab from the lat strain may not have been as quick as we, as fans, would have liked, it does seem like the progress is good.  When it comes to strains like that one, it is better to get it completely healed, and from everything we’ve been told, that seems to be the case.  Now, it’s just a matter of getting him stretched out sufficiently to start at the major league level.
  • Ian Stewart had a real setback the other night when he got hit on the elbow.  He missed last night’s game, and is playing tonight.  I get it.  Most of you out there think Ian is a bum, and he’s not worth the peanuts the Cubs are paying him this season, you want Tyler Colvin back, etc.  I’m going to continue to defend him, and the front office for bringing him back.  At least until he’s had time to finish a cup of coffee with the major league team.  His numbers aren’t good at Iowa, but he’s in the same boat as Garza.  He’s getting his timing back and working through the Spring Training process.  Unlike everyone in these games he’s playing, he’s still working the bugs out from not playing in about 11 months.  Let’s see him healthy and for a while in the bigs before we write him off.  We, as Cubs fans, should know that if he hits the streets before he gets all the way back, he’s going to go somewhere else, and be the third baseman we want him to be at Wrigley.

Neither of these players is going to be the savior to what is sure to be an uncompetitive season.  They do, however, make the Cubs deeper (in spite of your feelings for Stewart).  Getting Garza back will likely push Scott Feldman (because Travis Wood and Carlos Villanueva have earned the right to be in the rotation thus far) to the bullpen, as a long reliever.  Since he’s been good for three or four inning stretches this season, maybe being the long man will add to his value.  The same with Luis Valbuena.  If Ian Stewart can come back and take hold of the third base job, the Cubs will have two versatile infielders who can play all over in Valbuena and Cody Ransom, who hit from each side of the plate.  With Scott Hairston, Julio Borbon, and Dioner Navarro rounding out the bench, suddenly the Cubs don’t look quite so sad.

There are a lot of ifs in those statements.  I’m sure not all of it will come true.  Ian Stewart could come back, lay an egg, and be designated for assignment within a few weeks.  We don’t know.  But that is what the 2013 season is for.  Finding out who’s got value and who’s not going to be with the team moving forward is what the plan was for this season.

In the mean time, just enjoy the winning streak.